our famous flavors

hand-dipped and half gallons

hard ice cream

Almond Joy

Bing Cherry

Black Raspberry

Black Forest

Blueberry Cheesecake

Brownie Nut Fudge

Bubble Gum

Butter Pecan

Chocolate

Chocolate Almond

Chocolate Almond Chip

Chocolate Chip

Chocolate Fudge Brownie

Chocolate Marshmallow

Coffee

Coffee Fudge

Cookies and Cream

Cookie Dough

Dulce de Leche

Golden Vanilla

Maple Walnut

Mint Chocolate Chip

Moose Tracks

Party Cake

Peanut Butter Cookie

Peanut Butter Cup

Peanut Butter Swirl

Pineapple

Pistachio

Strawberry

Strawberry Cheesecake

Vanilla

Vanilla Fudge

sugar-free hard ice cream

Bing Cherry

Butter Pecan

Chocolate Mint

Moose Tracks

Strawberries and Cream

Vanilla

Vanilla/Chocolate Swirl

soft ice cream

Chocolate

Vanilla

Vanilla/Chocolate Swirl

sherbet

Fruit Bowl

Lemon-Lime

Orange

Raspberry

seasonal flavors

hand-dipped and half gallons

hard ice cream

Apple Pie

Banana

Banana Strawberry

Blueberry Swirl

Blueberry Pie

Butter Brickle

Cherry Chipper

Chunky Gorilla

Coconut

Coconut Fudge

Creamsicle

Egg Nog

English Toffee

French Vanilla

German Chocolate Cake

Lemon Cream Pie

Mocha Almond Fudge

Orange Pineapple

Peach

Pecan Praline

Peppermint Stick

Pumpkin Spice

Pumpkin Cheesecake

Reese's Pieces

Rocky Road

Rum Raisin

Snickers

Strawberry Marshmallow

Teaberry

soft ice cream

Black Raspberry

Peach

Strawberry

ordering

how to order

Ordering ice cream cakes from The Bethlehem Dairy Store is easy!

cake sizes:

Round

  • 6" (feeds approx 4-6)
  • 8" (feeds approx 6-12)
  • 9" (feeds approx 10-14)
  • 10" (feeds approx 12-20)
  • 12" (feeds approx 25+)

Sheet cake

  • 9x13" (feeds approx 20-25)

linden street

The Linden Street location has much more than just ice cream! We also carry dairy products - milk, butter, OJ, eggs, bread, and hot food - hot dogs, fries, pierogies, nachos and much more!

  • 1430 Linden Street
  • Bethlehem, PA 18018

campus square

  • 2 Campus Square (at New and Morton Streets)
  • Bethlehem, PA 18018

contact us

We can be reached by phone at one of our two locations:

  • Linden Street Store:
  • 610-691-8422
  • Campus Square Store:
  • 610-865-4360

If you have suggestions or questions, please email us at: info@bethlehemdairystore.com

ice cream

about us

the cup lehigh

our history

For the past 85 years, The Bethlehem Dairy Store has been a favorite of area families looking to enjoy many flavors of homemade ice cream. Back in the 1920's and 30's, families would line up along the outside of the store on Linden Street to watch Soap-box derby races and then head to the store for ice cream. You may hear many long-time residents refer to the store as "The Cup", due to its original shape as a large milkshake cup. Other people may refer to the store as "Mowrer's," in honor of the long time ownership by the Mowrer family.

For over the past 20 years, William Burkhardt and Frederick Buckenmeyer have been co-owners of the Bethlehem Dairy Store, Inc. In late August 2002, they opened an additional location on the campus of Lehigh University, in the Campus Square retail area. They also operate 3 stands at Musikfest, Bethlehem's arts and music festival held in early August, in addition to participating in a variety of other local festivals.